Skip to content

Uncorrelated does not always mean independent

Two variables can have zero covariance while one remains determined by the other through a non-linear relationship.

On this page

Specify a complete finite model

Let X take −1, 0 and 1 with equal probabilities, and let Y = X². This is an original illustrative probability model, not a return forecast.

The three possible pairs
XY = X²Probability
−111/3
001/3
111/3

Calculate the covariance

E(X) = 0, E(Y) = 2/3 and E(XY) = E(X³) = 0. Covariance is E(XY) − E(X)E(Y), so it is zero. Both variables have positive variance: Var(X) = 2/3 and Var(Y) = 2/9. Their Pearson correlation is therefore zero with a valid positive denominator.

Test a conditional probability

Before observing Y, P(X = 0) = 1/3. Given Y = 0, the model requires X = 0, so P(X = 0|Y = 0) = 1. The information changes the probability, establishing dependence despite zero correlation.

Avoid turning a linear statistic into a general relationship test

The negative and positive covariance contributions cancel in this symmetric model. The non-linear mapping remains exact. Use the model’s joint distribution or appropriate dependence analysis when the question is broader than linear co-movement.

Further references