On this page
Taxes change the cash available to meet a liability, while duration describes how the value of assets and liabilities responds to interest rates. In a CFA® Level III liability-driven investing problem, first define the obligation and the investor’s tax position, then compare after-tax asset cash flows and interest-rate sensitivity on the same basis. A duration match based on gross yields alone can leave a funding gap.
Start with the liability, not the bond
Liability-driven investing, or LDI, begins with a payment the portfolio must support. A pension plan may owe a series of benefits, an insurer may face contractual claims, and an individual may have a specified future spending need. The amount, timing and certainty of those payments determine the relevant asset portfolio. CFA Institute’s LDI refresher reading distinguishes a single known liability from multiple obligations and explains why cash-flow matching and duration matching serve different cases.
If a liability has a known payment date and amount, a default-free zero-coupon asset maturing on that date is the conceptual clean match, assuming its net proceeds suffice. Coupon-bearing bonds introduce reinvestment risk because interim cash must be invested until the payment date. Matching Macaulay duration to the horizon can offset the first-order effects of a yield change on price and reinvestment income. It is an approximation that needs monitoring; it is not a promise that every yield-curve movement will leave the funding position unchanged.
For several liabilities, the comparison moves from a single date to a stream of payments. Present values put both sides on a common valuation date. Money duration combines market value and modified duration, so it measures approximate currency sensitivity to a small parallel rate change. The asset side and liability side can have equal percentage durations yet different currency changes if their present values differ. In a surplus account, that distinction is especially important: matching the two duration numbers mechanically may create exposure in the surplus.
The tax step comes before the yield comparison
A taxable investor cannot spend a gross coupon that must partly be paid as tax. For a simple illustrative comparison, a bond yielding 6% before tax at an assumed 30% tax rate leaves 4.2% after a tax on that income. A qualifying tax-exempt bond yielding an illustrative 4.4% would then provide more spendable income under those narrow assumptions. The comparison is not a universal preference for either security. Credit quality, call features, price, timing, tax jurisdiction and the actual tax treatment must also be aligned.
The breakeven rate is the tax rate at which the taxable bond’s retained yield equals the exempt yield. In this invented case, one minus 4.4 divided by 6 is about 26.7%. Below that rate, the taxable bond’s simple after-tax yield is higher; above it, the exempt bond’s simple yield is higher. This is arithmetic for a hypothetical candidate exercise, not a tax rule or quoted market yield. It isolates one input so the examiner can see that you understand why the investor’s status changes the relevant comparison.
A tax-exempt institution sees the same bonds differently because there is no assumed tax deduction from its interest income. In the simplified comparison, it compares the gross returns, adjusted for risk and cash-flow suitability. A taxable investor also needs to consider realised gains and losses if a duration rebalance requires trading. CFA Institute’s asset-allocation refresher explicitly treats taxes as a constraint on rebalancing. That is why tax efficiency and liability matching belong in the same portfolio discussion, even though they answer distinct analytical questions.
An illustrative surplus calculation
Suppose a portfolio has assets worth 110 units and a liability worth 100 units today. The asset portfolio has modified duration 5 and the liability has modified duration 8. These are invented round numbers. If the relevant yield curve falls by one percentage point and a first-order duration approximation applies, asset value rises by about 5.5 units, while liability value rises by about 8 units. The initial surplus of 10 units falls to about 7.5. An analyst who compared only the current 110 against 100 would miss that rate sensitivity.
To bring their approximate currency sensitivities together, the asset portfolio would need modified duration of about 7.27 under those values: 110 times 7.27 is roughly 100 times 8. That target differs from a simple instruction to make asset duration equal 8. The small calculation is the key candidate decision. With unequal market values, match money duration when the goal is to stabilise the surplus against a parallel shift. The calculation says nothing by itself about the credit or tax quality of assets chosen to reach the target.
Now suppose part of the asset cash flow is taxed before it can pay the obligation. A gross valuation that assumes all coupon income is available overstates the fundable asset side for that taxable investor. In a real mandate, taxes can also alter the timing of usable cash and the result of selling bonds to rebalance. The portfolio manager must estimate net cash flows under the investor’s actual tax rules before concluding that the liability is covered. The simple duration calculation above isolates interest-rate risk; it does not incorporate tax cash flows automatically.
Where a matched duration still leaves risk
Duration is a local sensitivity measure. If the curve twists, the yields at the dates of different cash flows may change by different amounts. Assets and liabilities with the same aggregate money duration can then reprice differently. Different convexities also matter for larger rate moves. A portfolio can be interest-rate matched and still expose the surplus to credit spread widening, a downgrade, default, liquidity constraints or a change in the expected liability cash flow. The exam answer should state which risk is being controlled and which risks remain.
Cash-flow matching offers a different form of protection when a set of predictable assets can be arranged to pay obligations as they fall due. It may require more securities and may be costly or infeasible for a complex liability schedule. Duration matching is more flexible, yet it requires rebalancing as time passes and yields move. A candidate should not call one method universally superior. Choose between them by considering certainty of payment, available instruments, transaction costs and the tolerance for interim surplus movement.
If the amount or timing of a liability can change, a single Macaulay duration may be too crude. An option, benefit formula or uncertain claim can make cash flows move when rates or other conditions change. Effective duration and scenarios are then more useful because they recompute values under changed conditions. The question to ask is whether the liability behaves like a fixed bond or whether the cash flows themselves respond to the stress. A calculation built on fixed payments cannot capture a contingency that was never included.
How to answer the exam question
Write down the objective in a sentence: fund a dated payment, reduce surplus volatility, or maintain a liquidity reserve. Classify the liability’s cash flows, identify whether the investor is taxable, and use net cash flows for the funding test. For rate exposure, compare present values and money durations, not just the quoted yields. If the problem describes a falling-rate risk with short-duration assets, show why the liability rises more and specify the direction of the required asset-duration adjustment. Keep the tax and rate steps visibly separate so neither is accidentally omitted.
The common error is to say that matching asset and liability duration solves the problem without checking the amount on each side. In the illustrative surplus example, equal durations of 8 would give the 110-unit asset portfolio more money duration than the 100-unit liability. Another error is to choose the bond with the highest gross coupon for a taxable account, then ignore what remains after tax. Both mistakes turn a useful shortcut into a wrong conclusion. The fix is to state the relevant net cash flows and compute currency sensitivity explicitly.
The CFA programme page places fixed income in the wider qualification path; the how-it-works page can help you turn this concept into a repeatable revision sequence. For each practice scenario, ask what payment must be met, what cash is spendable, what rate shift is tested and whether the portfolio must be rebalanced. The strongest answer is a conditional one grounded in those facts, rather than a memorised instruction to add duration whenever a pension liability appears.
Sources
- Liability-Driven and Index-Based Strategies | CFA Institute · cfainstitute.org · Retrieved
- Asset Allocation with Real-World Constraints | CFA Institute · cfainstitute.org · Retrieved



