Skip to content

New to Omni?·Get 20% off your first purchase with code WELCOME20 at checkout.See plans

FRM® financing deals: who bears the unsold issue risk?

Firm commitment, best efforts and private placement shift funding risk. Trace who buys the securities, who receives cash and what happens when demand is weak.

ConceptOmni Curriculum Team7 min read

A person holds blank securities beside another stack and a brass balance scale on a navy desk.
On this page

The quickest way to classify an investment banking financing arrangement is to ask whether the bank must buy the securities itself. Under a firm commitment it agrees, subject to the deal's conditions, to purchase the issue and carries resale risk. Under best efforts it tries to place securities for the issuer without taking the unsold balance; in a private placement it helps reach selected investors. The issuer's certainty of proceeds differs accordingly.

Why the bank's role matters

A company can need financing without having direct access to every investor who might supply it. An investment bank can structure the security, find potential buyers, help price the offering and distribute it. Those activities do not all put the same risk on the bank's balance sheet. The bank can act as a principal, buying securities and reselling them, or as an agent seeking investors for the issuer. To understand the economics, identify the contract between issuer and bank before following the later sale to investors.

GARP's FRM study materials place financial markets and products within Part I and describe official learning objectives as the guide to what candidates should be able to do. The concept here is a risk allocation problem disguised as a financing vocabulary question. A correct answer identifies who supplies cash to the issuer when outside demand is disappointing, not merely the name of the document or whether the securities are shares or bonds. The FRM programme page gives the broader exam context.

Firm commitment: purchase and resale

In a firm commitment underwriting, the bank or an underwriting group agrees to buy the issue from the issuer on the agreed terms if the transaction closes under its conditions. The SEC's description of firm and best efforts underwriting says the bank takes the economic risk of selling securities it has committed to purchase. The bank then seeks to resell them to investors. The difference between what investors pay and what the bank pays the issuer is the underwriting spread before other expenses. If resale demand is weak, the bank cannot simply charge the issuer for every unsold security under the basic firm commitment model.

The phrase “guaranteed proceeds” needs care. It refers to the bank's purchase obligation once the agreed commitment is operative and applicable closing conditions are satisfied. It does not mean that every proposed offering closes regardless of legal, regulatory or contractual events. The practical exam distinction remains clear: once the bank is bound to purchase the securities, failure to find outside buyers is principally its resale problem. A bank can manage that exposure through distribution work and by sharing an issue within a syndicate, but sharing does not turn a firm purchase into best efforts.

Consider an invented example. A company issues one million shares. The bank agrees to buy them at £9 each and plans to sell them at £10. If all shares sell at £10, the issuer receives £9 million and the bank's gross spread is £1 million before its costs. If only 700,000 sell at £10 and the other 300,000 have to be sold at £8, the bank collects £7 million plus £2.4 million, or £9.4 million, against its £9 million purchase cost. Its gross result is £400,000. The issuer still receives £9 million under the assumed completed commitment. These are illustrative numbers, not observed issue terms.

Change only the weak-demand resale price to £6. The bank then collects £7 million plus £1.8 million, or £8.8 million, and has a £200,000 gross loss before costs. The bank's planned spread did not protect it from all price movements. This second case is useful because an exam response that always labels the spread “profit” misses the difference between an intended offer price and the average price actually achieved. Calculate the bank's total resale proceeds before subtracting its fixed acquisition cost.

Best efforts: an agency service

Under best efforts, the bank undertakes to try to sell the issue but does not undertake to buy the unsold portion. The SEC's explanation explicitly contrasts this obligation with firm commitment underwriting. The bank is usually compensated for successful distribution according to the agreement, while the issuer bears the risk that less than the desired amount is raised. Terms can include thresholds or other conditions; candidates should read the arrangement rather than assume every partial sale completes on identical terms.

Use the same invented one million shares, but now suppose a best efforts agent offers them at £10 and earns an illustrative 2% fee on shares actually sold. If all sell, gross investor payments are £10 million, the fee is £200,000, and the issuer receives £9.8 million before any other expenses. If only 700,000 sell and the agreement permits a partial completion, gross payments are £7 million, the fee is £140,000, and issuer proceeds are £6.86 million before other expenses. The remaining shares do not become the bank's inventory merely because it tried to sell them.

Do not compare the £9.8 million best efforts net proceeds with the £9 million firm commitment purchase price and declare one structure universally superior. The examples specify different prices and fees precisely to show the trade-off. Best efforts can give a higher result when demand is strong but leaves the issuer exposed when demand is weak. A company that must fund a fixed project may value certainty differently from a company that can scale its spending. The contractual details and issuer's objective decide the practical importance of that risk.

Private placement: audience before risk

A private placement is identified first by the restricted investor audience rather than by a promise about unsold securities. The bank may introduce the issuer to eligible investors and assist with terms, receiving an arrangement fee under a particular mandate. The sale is not a public distribution simply because an investment bank is involved. Nor should “private placement” alone be read as proof that the bank has committed its own capital. The role of principal or agent must be established separately from the audience for the issue.

Suppose a company seeks £12 million from a small group of institutional investors. If the bank merely arranges subscriptions and earns an agreed fee, the issuer obtains only the subscriptions that actually close under the placement terms. If the bank separately agrees to purchase securities itself, that additional contractual promise changes its exposure. This distinction prevents a common classification mistake: treating “private” and “firm commitment” as opposites. One describes whom the securities are offered to; the other describes who must buy them. In the SEC's capital raising discussion, different routes of investor access and distribution are treated as separate choices.

IPO pricing and auction logic

An initial public offering adds a pricing problem: the company's shares lack an established public trading price before the issue. A bank may estimate demand and set terms with the issuer, but an indicated investor interest is not the same as a completed sale. In a firm commitment, the bank's exposure is to the difference between its purchase obligation and what resale ultimately achieves. Under best efforts, a price that attracts too few buyers leaves the issuer with a funding shortfall, subject to the agreement's completion conditions.

A uniform-price auction is a different pricing method, not automatically a different answer to the principal-versus-agent question. The SEC describes an auction in which investors bid quantities and prices, the issue is priced at the highest price that sells the full amount, and successful investors pay the same offer price. Imagine, illustratively, 100,000 shares and bids for 40,000 at £12, 35,000 at £11 and 50,000 at £10. Demand first covers supply at £10, so the clearing price is £10. The first two bid groups are eligible, while only 25,000 of the 50,000 shares bid at £10 can be allocated under a simple rationing rule. All successful bidders pay £10. The bids reveal a clearing price; they do not by themselves tell you who has agreed to purchase unsold securities if the offering fails to close.

A reliable exam sequence

When a question gives a financing description, mark the investor audience, the bank's legal purchase obligation and the payment flow in that order. If the bank buys and resells, compute its gross result from actual resale receipts less its purchase cost. If the bank only places, compute issuer cash from securities sold less the agreed fee, while checking any minimum-sale condition. If a price is set by auction, derive the clearing level from cumulative eligible bids and then return to the contract to locate placement risk.

The mistake most likely to spoil an otherwise correct answer is to confuse underwriting spread with an unconditional bank profit. Another is to call best efforts “insurance” for the issuer's financing target. A final one is to infer risk allocation from the word IPO or private placement without reading the actual commitment. Those labels are useful context, but the signed obligation and the completed cash flow carry the answer. For study planning, Omni's methodology is a separate resource; this calculation should stand on its own whenever you see a financing vignette.

Sources

  1. FRM Study Materials | GARP · garp.org · Retrieved
  2. SEC Complaint: Prousalis and Kirk · sec.gov · Retrieved
  3. Raising Capital on the Internet | SEC · sec.gov · Retrieved

Explore FRM study resources

Educational content, not investment advice. This article is written to help candidates prepare for professional exams. It is not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security, and it does not take your personal circumstances into account.

Omni Finance Academy is an independent exam-preparation provider and is not affiliated with or endorsed by CFA Institute, GARP, CAIA Association or CFP Board. CFA®, FRM®, CAIA® and CFP® are trademarks of their respective owners. Full disclaimer.