Skip to content

Uncorrelated variables that are dependent

For X uniformly drawn from −1, 0 and 1, Y=X² is dependent on X even though covariance is zero.

On this page

List every state

Original discrete model
XY = X²ProbabilityXY
−111/3−1
001/30
111/31

Calculate the cross moment

E[X]=0, E[Y]=2/3 and E[XY]=0. Cov(X,Y)=E[XY]−E[X]E[Y]=0. Var(X)=2/3 and Var(Y)=2/9, so both standard deviations are positive and correlation is zero.

Check a conditional event

P(Y=0)=1/3. Given X=0, Y must be 0, so P(Y=0|X=0)=1. The changed conditional probability establishes dependence. In fact Y is determined by X in this model.

Keep the inference narrow

Covariance captures this second-moment relationship. Zero covariance does not generally rule out nonlinear dependence. The example does not supply a portfolio return forecast; it shows why a correlation label alone cannot describe every dependence risk.

Further references