Skip to content

Counting an investable universe with overlapping exclusion lists

From 1,200 issuers, lists containing 38, 61 and 22 issuers remove 117 unique issuers when exactly four appear in both the second and third lists and there are no other overlaps.

On this page

Specify every overlap needed for the calculation

The fictional universe has 1,200 distinct issuers. List A contains 38, B contains 61 and C contains 22. Exactly four issuers belong to both B and C. A has no overlap with either other list, and there is no three-way overlap. Without these last conditions, the three counts and one overlap would not determine the union.

Count the union once

Adding the list lengths gives 121 entries, but the four shared B–C issuers are each counted twice. Subtract their extra appearances once: 38 + 61 + 22 − 4 = 117 unique exclusions.

Counting distinct exclusions
StepCount
List memberships before deduplication121
Extra appearances from the B–C overlap4
Unique excluded issuers117
Eligible issuers: 1,200 − 1171,083

Check the no-overlap shortcut

Subtracting 121 directly from the universe gives 1,079, four too few eligible issuers. The error is double-counting the four shared exclusions. It is not evidence that a fourth exclusion list exists.

Extend the idea to three overlapping lists

If every pair can overlap, inclusion–exclusion subtracts all three pairwise intersections and then adds the three-way intersection back once. In a real worksheet, stable issuer identifiers are preferable to company-name matching because spelling differences and subsidiaries can obscure duplicate records.

Further references